Five Things We the Church Need Know About Technological Change (3 of 5): There is a Powerful Idea Embedded in Every Technology

In: Tools for Tech Thinking

20 Dec 2008

This is part 3 of a five part series based on Neil Postman’s lecture “Five Things We Need to Know about Technological Change” applied to the church.

3. There is a Powerful Idea Embedded in Every Technology

My friend Trey is an artist and a story teller.

Whether he has his camera in hand or not, he sees the world as pictures that tell stories. His recent photography and video editing work on www.iamsecond.com shows his skill, sensitivity, and passion (its gotten great Nintendo Wii – By definition you play the Wii inside, but every 20 minutes or so, it tells you that you should go outside and play. This may not seem like a big deal, but when a $250 product is telling you “Stop using me,” that’s pretty amazing.

ROOV – For all the personal connections that Social Networks allow, they also encourage us to relate through a technology and not face to face. ROOV on the other hand is specifically designed to facilitate “offline” face to face relationships.

Perhaps if we spend some time thinking like Nintendo and Roov, we could enable the beautiful story-tellers, like Trey, while avoiding some of the pitfalls into which even great leaders like King David fell.

Tags: bush, david, obama, photography, Postman, radio, video

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

Placebo Relationships « The Pugnacious Irishman

43Comments2008-12-20+15%3A42%3A00John+Dyer to Five Things We the Church Need Know About Technological Change (3 of 5): There is a Powerful Idea Embedded in Every Technology

nick charalambous

December 21st, 2008 at 10:14 pm

It’s refreshing to hear a critical approach toward technology and the church/evangelism, which doesn’t at the same time discount its benefits. For me there’s a couple of reasons to be wary: 1)technology puts a tremendous temptation in front of people to focus on the ingenuity of man, not the God who made him and gave him the ingenuity. And 2) technology always presents the opportunity to increase noise in our lives. What gives me hope is that the more man-centered our world gets, the more God-hungry we become … and as Christ followers, we have the power and the wisdom to use the tools by which Satan enslaves to set those very same captives free.

Reply
- John Dyer
  
  December 24th, 2008 at 9:32 am
  
  @Nick, it’s great to hear from a brother in the UK. I agree that it’s tough to walk the line between critiquing and yet not completely rejecting technology. Your insight is great.
  
  Reply
Lex

December 22nd, 2008 at 10:10 am

So (just because I’m curious and I’m trying to bring the point home for myself) what are some technologies that you think we’ve brought into the church that may have powerful ideas embedded in them (for or contrary to the gospel)?

I’m trying to think about it on my end and I’m not coming up with much. Overhead screens, for example. Does that encourage the idea that weekend services are one more entertainment venue, or does it encourage the idea that the Church should be relevant to it’s culture?

Reply
- John Dyer
  
  December 24th, 2008 at 9:41 am
  
  @Lex,
  Great question. I’ll try to just give a few examples:
  
  Postman give the example of how King Solomon was praised in his day for knowing 3000 proverbs. In a world before writing was common, memorization and oral recitation were valued with many Jews in Jesus’ day memorized the entire Pentateuch.
  
  Now that writing has become more common and everyone has a printed Bible, we have more access to the Scriptures than at any other time in history. Yet almost no one knows more than a few verses by heart. We don’t seem nearly as adept at “meditating on it day and night.”
  
  A more modern example would be how the video camera tends to be performance oriented. We usually pose to look our best for photographs and the same often happens with video cameras. For example, Richard Dortch, who was involved in the Bakker scandal of the 1980s said:
  
  ‘A television camera can change a preacher quicker than anything else. Those who sit on the sidelines can notice the changes in people once they get in front of a camera. It turns a good man into a potentate. It is so easy to get swept away by popularity: Everybody loves you, cars are waiting for you, and you go to the head of the line. That is the devastation of the camera. It has made us less than God has wanted us to become.’
  
  Reply
Eric D

December 22nd, 2008 at 1:40 pm

John,

You make a good point with your example of King David. Without the resources available to him, he couldn’t have done a census at all. Like you say, “most technology has the embedded message of “speed” which says, “don’t think about technology – just try to keep up!” The same could be said of just about any thing ministers covet because they believe it will help their ministry succeed.
How many times do I have to hear, “if only we had this new building for our church, we could do more ministry and.” As if a building is going to woe the lost to come through the church doors. I guess the same could be said for websites and the like.

Reply
Charles

December 23rd, 2008 at 10:48 pm

I think most technology has one embedded message in common, among the others: life or work will be easier. It’s helpful if we’re trying to make a necessary and effective ministry more efficient.

But a lot of times we get some new technology, and do things because we can, not because we should. Then, because we weren’t committed to the spirit of project, we we waste time and effort doing it poorly, instead of putting the energy and planning in that might make it succeed.

Reply
Rich Bordner

January 6th, 2009 at 1:46 am

Wow…great post. I gave this a thumbs up on Stumbleupon. More people in the church need to be exposed to this thinking.

Reply
Rich Bordner

January 6th, 2009 at 11:23 pm

Because I’m a teacher and I work with youth, I’ve blogged on this subject quite a bit lately. Here is a link to some of those posts. I hope they can add to this already excellent discussion in a significant way:

http://pugnaciousirishman.wordpress.com/tag/technology/

Reply
busby seo test

January 12th, 2009 at 11:04 pm

great!!interesting!!thanks for the information

Reply

Leave a Reply

About this blog

I'm John Dyer a web developer working on sites like Best Commentaries and Dallas Seminary. I'm also a seminary graduate and teacher at Irving Bible Church.

This blog is about the influence of technology on humanity. I think technology is an amazing testament to human creativity and the imago dei, but instead of assuming technology is always a neutral tool, I believe it profoundly influences us.

Upcoming Posts

Aristotle’s Ethics and the Goal of Online Relationships
Click-Through Activism vs. Active Love
Learning from Buber: I-Thou and I-It
Two Weeks with an Old Friend: The Newspaper
Speed and Suffering
Technology Metaphors in Literature
Memory, forgiveness, and backed up hard drives
I marginalize my father through technology
Pornography and Knowing
Loving the lord with all your mind in a digital age

Categories

Archives

Recent Comments
Recent Posts
Tags

Matt Huggins: Practically speaking, prioritizing modes of personal interaction serves as a decent starting point. [...]
johndyer: Jonathan, could you elaborate more on how and why you make decisions about "category and import [...]
johndyer: Thanks for sharing the quote from Bounds. Historical perspective is always helpful. [...]
Jonathan Louie: I try to filter who is more important on my lists. For twitter I know who I just glance at and th [...]
Matt Huggins: Perhaps a bit afield from the personal coping discussion, here is a quote from Power through Prayer, [...]

Asides

Internet Fatigue
CNN has a report on the phenomenon of internet fatigue. I wish they would have spent more time on giving suggestions for how to understand why this happens and how to avoid it. (0)

Articles and Tools on Texting
The NYTimes has a new article on the effects of texting on youth which include anxiety, sleep deprivation, and hand injuries. Interestingly, as Andy Crouch points out, the article also mentions that teens send many texts to their parents, meaning that teens are now connected to their parents more often during the day – a time when teenagers of the past were developing independence. LG has also created a new site to help parents decode text messages. (0)

Course Syllabus: Writing for Nonreaders in the Postprint Era
A humorous, but enlightening syllabus for a class on writing in the “postprint” era. Writing for nonreaders in the postprint era: “Students will examine why former generations carried around heavy clumps of bound paper and why they chose to read instead of watching TV or playing Guitar Hero.” (0)

Language Shapes Our Worldview
A psychology professor at Stanford University found that in languages with gender, the gender assigned to an objects tends to shape the way a speaker views that’s object. For example, in Spanish, “bridge” is masculine so Spanish speakers describe bridges as “strong” and “dangerous,” while German speakers for whom bridge is feminine tend to describe bridges as “fragile” and “beautiful.” Perhaps our own understanding of words like redemption, wrath, and adoption are also shaped by unseen factors. (0)

Survey Says Facebook Users Get Lower Grades
A study from educational researches at the Ohio State University found that students who regularly used facebook only study 1-5 hours per week and had GPAs in the 3.0-3.5 range, while non-facebook users study around 11-15 hours per week with GPAs in the 3.5-4.0 range. I wonder how church education compares? (0)

Risk-Reducing Technologies Increase Risk-Taking
The Pope and a Harvard scientist make an interesting argument that AIDS is increasing in Africa precisely because of condom distribution. More... (0)